On this page

Repair choice and a damaged product are different questions

The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) interpretation addresses conditions requiring specified-brand articles or services. It distinguishes items/services provided without charge and an actual Commission waiver. A parts-only limited warranty also cannot use the supply of replacement parts to prevent the consumer choosing the labour provider.

The rule separately permits a warrantor to exclude defects or damage caused by unauthorised parts or service, or deny liability where it can demonstrate that cause. An independent repair alone is therefore different from supported evidence that it caused the claimed fault.

Sources: Federal Trade Commission; eCFR: 700.10(a)–(c): brand/service conditions, free-item/service and waiver boundaries, damage causation

A service visit does not explain every later fault

Fictional example: a customer pays an independent business for routine maintenance. Later, a different covered component fails. The distributor proposes rejecting every warranty claim because the customer did not use the branded maintenance service.

The owner should ask which actual condition is being imposed and what evidence connects the claimed fault to the outside work. This example determines neither coverage nor causation. It shows why a general void-warranty response can skip the important distinction.

Review the words the customer actually receives

Check leaflets, websites, packaging and service conversations together. A narrow clause is not enough if the customer repeatedly receives a broader message.

Message or decisionQuestion to resolve
Authorised service requiredIs this an actual covered/no-charge service, a supported exception or an impermissible paid-service condition?
Branded replacements requiredWhat is provided free, and what is merely a required purchase?
Damage caused by outside workWhat specific fault and evidence support the causal explanation?
Distributor script or repair formDoes it imply a broader loss of coverage than the operative terms allow?
Claim handlingWho reviews scope and evidence rather than applying a blanket rejection code?

Price the service without an unsupported lock-in

Define what the authorised network offers customers and what it actually promises to pay or perform. Keep private reimbursement and local service capacity in their own plan.

Use the relationship worksheet to assign review and service responsibilities. It does not decide an actual warranty claim, grant a waiver or determine every applicable state repair law.

Scope

  • Selected federal anti-tying interpretation only. No actual repair, cause, claim, exception, waiver or state repair-access right is determined.

Next step

Use the Relationship factsheet to separate warranty coverage, paid maintenance, actual covered repair and claim-review responsibility. Keep the wording and fault evidence in the authorised service file.

Sources & review notes

Access dates show when a source was retrieved. Review dates show when its meaning was checked. Editing this guide does not recheck the law.

16 CFR 700.10 — Prohibited tying

Federal Trade Commission; eCFR

Passage, dates and research notes

regulation · 700.10(a)–(c): brand/service conditions, free-item/service and waiver boundaries, damage causation

Accessed: 2026-11-16T10:36:09.023313+00:00 · Meaning reviewed: 2026-11-16T10:49:22.083866+00:00 · Next review target: 2026-12-16

Read the complete section. The article distinguishes independent non-warranty maintenance from actual covered repair service and does not promise that every third-party repair preserves every claim.

Detailed rule records (1)
Separate a brand/service condition from actual damage caused Depends on the facts

Section 700.10 interprets the anti-tying prohibition: coverage cannot generally depend on buying specified-brand articles/services. It distinguishes no-charge items/services and an actual FTC waiver, and permits properly scoped treatment of defects or damage caused by unauthorised articles/service.

When to check: Conditioning an applicable written consumer warranty on branded parts or authorised non-warranty service. Source review: 2026-11-16.

16 CFR 700.10 — Prohibited tying
Your learning

Bookmark this guide or mark it as read.

Learning library
Progress privacy

Saving is off by default. Without it, progress lasts only on this page. If you turn it on, this browser profile stores public content IDs and the progress you record. Anyone sharing the profile could see them. No plan inputs or contact details are included. Reset or export in learning settings.

This is a reading aid, not evidence of disclosure delivery, expertise or legal approval.