On this page
The rating condition is the issue
The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) rule prohibits a business buying or incentivising consumer reviews on an express or implied condition that they express a particular positive or negative sentiment. Its review definition includes ratings without written comments.
The FTC FAQ distinguishes an incentive not conditioned on sentiment, while retaining disclosure and other checks. This provision concerns consumer reviews; hired-influencer testimonials are not automatically the same category.
The request can imply a condition
Fictional example: a retailer offers a discount after a consumer posts a five-star rating. Another draft asks customers to describe how much they loved the product to qualify. Review both the explicit rating requirement and the implied positive outcome.
Ask whether an honest negative review could receive the same benefit under the actual process. That question does not approve the programme: reviewer selection, disclosure, authenticity and platform terms still matter.
Check the request and the reward process
A reward-processing script can impose a condition absent from the public page. Check both.
| Record | Question |
|---|---|
| Format | Consumer review/rating, testimonial or another endorsement? |
| Benefit | What money, discount, product or other value is offered? |
| Condition | Can honest feedback receive the benefit regardless of sentiment? |
| Staff and scripts | Do messages or conversations imply praise is required? |
| Other duties | What disclosure, authenticity and platform conditions apply? |
Keep the owner’s decision tied to evidence
Ask for the actual request, eligibility rules, fulfilment process and responsibility for checking it. Removing a rating condition does not make fabricated experience acceptable.
Assign the review before the campaign starts. The launch worksheet tracks responsibility; it does not purchase reviews or certify platform terms.
Scope
- Selected consumer-review provision and fictional requests only. No review programme, neutral incentive, platform use or complete advertising compliance is approved.
Next step
Use Launch dependencies to assign format, incentive-condition, disclosure and platform checks. Keep the campaign and reward records separately.
Sources & review notes
Federal Trade Commission; eCFR
Passage, dates and research notes
regulation · Complete 465.4: incentives conditioned expressly or implicitly on sentiment
Read the complete section. Consumer-review scope is retained; no universal classification of business references is supplied.
Federal Trade Commission; eCFR
Passage, dates and research notes
regulation · 465.1(a),(d),(f),(m): business, review/rating, testimonial and purchase
Read the complete definitions section; only the specified distinctions are used. Ratings without narrative are included.
U.S. Federal Trade Commission
Passage, dates and research notes
official-guidance · Definitions discussion and complete 465.4 FAQ: sentiment, disclosure and hired-influencer distinction
Read the selected discussion and complete 465.4 FAQ. No source fictional business or example is reproduced.
Detailed rule records (1)
Section 465.4 prohibits compensation/incentives exchanged for or expressly/impliedly conditioned on reviews expressing a particular positive or negative sentiment. Disclosure does not cure that condition.
16 CFR 465.4 — Buying positive or negative consumer reviews 16 CFR 465.1 — Consumer review definitions Consumer Reviews and Testimonials Rule: Questions and AnswersBookmark this guide or mark it as read.
Progress privacy
Saving is off by default. Without it, progress lasts only on this page. If you turn it on, this browser profile stores public content IDs and the progress you record. Anyone sharing the profile could see them. No plan inputs or contact details are included. Reset or export in learning settings.
This is a reading aid, not evidence of disclosure delivery, expertise or legal approval.