On this page
What the dated primary record establishes
The Federal Maritime Commission (FMC)’s April 2022 initial decision addressed eleven empty containers handled by a trucking company. It found insufficient return appointments on some charged days and unreasonable detention practices; it did not find every disputed charge unreasonable. The official law reporter retains that decision.
The FMC later announced a settlement and separately reported that Hapag-Lloyd paid US$2 million in June 2022. Those records distinguish an initial finding, settlement and actual civil-penalty payment. They do not establish a refund entitlement, fault allocation or current charge rule for your shipment.
Test the decision in your own operation
Build ELN’s day-by-day record for the actual container. A general statement that the port was congested is weaker than instructions and permitted appointment evidence tied to the equipment and relevant day. Protect commercial records and follow the actual dispute process.
| Record to establish | Evidence to bring | Owner decision |
|---|---|---|
| Container and clock | Correct equipment reference, free-time terms and relevant dates | Which day and charge are actually disputed? |
| Return instructions | Named location, permitted equipment type and changed instructions | Was the proposed return route usable for this container? |
| Opportunity and attempt | Reliable appointment availability, attempted booking and response evidence | Which facts explain why return did or did not occur? |
| Invoice and dispute | Charged period, actual correspondence, authorised adjustment and open issue | Who checks the evidence and keeps the dispute moving? |
Resolve the next commitment
Fictional example: the carrier’s instruction names depot A, while a booking record shows that depot would not accept that container type on the charged day. Keep both records and establish the actual alternative offered. This does not automatically determine legal liability; it makes the factual question reviewable.
Use Relationship factsheet to assign the carrier, trucking company, customer and dispute coordinator. Keep the container-day ledger, invoices and legal assessment in the shipment file. Avoid duplicate collection instructions while a return plan changes.
Scope
- The direct final settlement-order URL was inaccessible; the article uses the retained initial decision and official later settlement/payment accounts without asserting unreviewed final terms.
- Historical findings are not today’s complete detention rules or an individual refund decision. Actual contract, invoice and current requirements need their own assessment.
Next step
A container-day record connecting return instructions, appointment attempts, available slots, fee assessment and dispute owner. Identify who collects appointment evidence, checks the invoice and obtains the authorised resolution.
Terms used here
- Detention
- In this case, charges for holding an empty container beyond its allowed free period outside the terminal; actual terms and applicable requirements still matter.
- Free time
- The period allowed before the specified charge begins; its start, end and conditions depend on the actual shipment terms and requirements.
Sources & review notes
Federal Maritime Commission, official law reporter
Passage, dates and research notes
agency-initial-decision · Volume 4, printed pp. 53–54: initial-decision posture, eleven containers, return-appointment evidence and bounded findings
This initial decision found some disputed charges unreasonable, rather than every charge for all eleven containers. It is distinguished from the later settlement and payment accounts.
Federal Maritime Commission
Passage, dates and research notes
agency-settlement-release · Complete substantive settlement announcement: agreed $2m penalty, prior initial decision and case identity
This official announcement describes the settlement. The final settlement instrument was not accessed, so unreviewed final terms or a non-admission provision are not inferred.
Federal Maritime Commission
Passage, dates and research notes
agency-payment-release · Substantive body’s Hapag-Lloyd paragraph: actual June 2022 $2m payment, separate from ONE/Wan Hai transactions
Page metadata records publication on 18 May 2023. The Hapag-Lloyd paragraph reports actual June 2022 payment of US$2 million. Other carriers’ refund and non-admission terms are not attributed to Hapag-Lloyd.
Bookmark this guide or mark it as read.
Progress privacy
Saving is off by default. Without it, progress lasts only on this page. If you turn it on, this browser profile stores public content IDs and the progress you record. Anyone sharing the profile could see them. No plan inputs or contact details are included. Reset or export in learning settings.
This is a reading aid, not evidence of disclosure delivery, expertise or legal approval.